Penny Lane

 apartment building  Add category

8-story/7-story cooperative-apartment building originally completed in as a 6-story ice cream factory in 1910. Designed by Frank Goodwillie for the J.M. Horton Ice Cream Company, it was significantly altered and converted to residential use in 1977, including a complete gut renovation. Many of the new apartments featured direct access doors to the street, and there was also a large English Tudor lobby – designed to resemble a London Street. Part of the lobby is up several steps and has faux "streetfronts" and lampposts.

The long facade is clad in buff-colored brick, with some concrete planters in front. The building is divided into two sections, with the western one rising to eight floors, and the slightly wider eastern section having seven floors. The east section is arranged into four main bays on the upper floors, each with a pair of glass sliding doors with transoms opening onto shallow concrete balconies with angled sides and metal railings. The bays are slightly recessed, with beveled edges of the brick next to them. The sets of glass doors are each separated by a brick pilaster running up the middle. On either side of each bay, in the brick spaces, there are rectangular metal air-conditioning vents. The 2-story base along the east section is topped by a band ornamented with some small medallions and rosettes, and capitals for the dark-green stone piers that surround the areas around the main entrance, at the 2nd bay from the west. It has sliding wood-and-glass doors below a rounded, black canvas canopy extending out over the sidewalk. Above, there are four glass panes at the 2nd floor. There is a 2-story window opening to the left, followed by a round-arched entrance to one of the duplexes that line much of the base of the building. Like the others, it has a white wooden door and paneled sidelight atop a single step. Above it is a horizontal window, with two more to the left (one on each level). A tall double-window to the left of that begins the transition to the west section. East of the main entrance, framed by dark-green stone piers, are three bays of double-windows on both floors of the base. There are then two more duplex entrances, an entrance to the underground parking garage, and a final duplex entrance, with a horizontal window at the far east end. At the 2nd floor above each doorway is a recessed balcony with metal railings, accessed by sliding glass doors. There is a double-window above the garage entrance.

The base along the west section has, at its east end where it meets the east section, a set of sliding glass door with a tall transom on top. Continuing west there are two duplex entrances (like those on the east section, with recessed balconies above on the 2nd floor) paired together, then a single duplex entry, another pair of duplex entries, and a final duplex entrance. The upper floors have a center bay of sliding glass doors opening onto a very shallow balcony. To either side are two matching bay paired together, and then another bay at each end. They are have beveled brick edges and metal railings, and there are more air-conditioning vents next to each bay.

The building was converted to a co-op in 1988, with 180 apartments. There is an enormous rooftop deck that used to house paddleball courts.