This was the site of the Snug Saloon, built in 1879. The saloon was torn down in 1911 when the present structure was built as the Columbo Hotel by the Pons family. The hotel was re-named The Hotel Roosevelt for a short time, and later changed back to the Columbo Hotel. Later, 537 Main became the Green Door and later Elvira's Castle, a local watering hole for three generations of patrons.